Traditional Bathtubs vs. Walk-In Showers in Wausau, WI: Which is Right for Your Remodel?

When planning a bathroom remodel in Wausau, WI, homeowners often face a tough choice: sticking with the familiar comfort of traditional bathtubs or going for the modern flair of walk-in showers. 

This decision isn’t just about looks; it’s also about how you use your space, keeping things safe, and thinking about your home’s value down the line.

Let’s delve into the specifics to help you make an informed decision!

Walk-In Showers: Expanding on the Pros

Walk-in showers in Wausau, WI, are not just about their sleek design and space-saving benefits; they also promote a sense of openness and accessibility in your bathroom. With various customization options, from the choice of tiles to the installation of luxurious shower heads, walk-in showers can be tailored to suit any aesthetic.

Moreover, the ease of maintenance and cleaning associated with showers adds to their appeal, making them a practical choice for busy households.

Traditional Bathtubs vs. Walk-In Showers in Wausau, WI

Walk-In Tubs: A Closer Look at the Benefits

The walk-in bathtub market has evolved significantly, offering a wide range of models that cater to different needs and preferences. From soaker tubs with deep, relaxing depths to therapeutic options equipped with jets for hydrotherapy, walk-in tubs provide a sanctuary for relaxation and rejuvenation.

Furthermore, the added safety features of walk-in tubs, such as grab bars and anti-scald valves, ensure a secure and comfortable bathing experience, particularly for those with mobility issues or seniors aiming to age in place.

Evaluating Resale Value: Shower or Bathtub?

When considering the resale value of your home, it’s important to reflect on the potential preferences of future buyers. A walk-in shower may appeal to a broader audience, offering a modern and accessible bathroom solution.

However, the inclusion of a walk-in tub in your Wausau, WI, home could also be a distinguishing feature, appealing to buyers looking for a safe and accessible bathroom. Ultimately, the decision should be based on a balance between your immediate needs and the potential future benefits.

Installation and Maintenance: Simplifying the Process

Regardless of whether you choose a walk-in shower or a walk-in tub, selecting the right professionals for installation and maintenance is crucial. Proper installation ensures that all safety features are operational and that your new bathroom fixture functions efficiently.

Regular maintenance is also key to prolonging the life of your bathroom remodel, whether it’s ensuring the seamless operation of a walk-in shower’s drainage system or maintaining the cleanliness and functionality of a walk-in tub’s jets and door seals.

Upgrade Your Wausau Bathroom with Us Today!

Take the first step towards your dream bathroom in Wausau, WI. Choose between the timeless beauty of traditional bathtubs and the sleek functionality of walk-in showers with Remodeling Journey. 

Dial (715) 551-7328 to schedule your consultation and begin your transformation journey!

The Pros and Cons of Walk-In Showers

The Pros The Cons
  • Modern Aesthetics: Walk-in showers embody contemporary design, offering clean lines and an open feel that can significantly enhance the visual space of your bathroom. Their sleek appearance fits well with modern homes in Wausau, WI, and can be a focal point of bathroom design.
  • Space Efficiency: By eliminating the bulk of a traditional bathtub, showers can make a bathroom feel larger and more accessible. This is especially beneficial in smaller bathrooms where conserving space is crucial.
  • Water Conservation: With the installation of low-flow shower heads, walk-in showers can be more water-efficient than full baths in traditional bathtubs. This not only conserves water but can also help reduce utility bills over time.
  • Accessibility: Walk-in showers offer easier access, particularly for those with mobility issues. The lack of a high threshold to step over reduces the risk of falls, making the bathroom safer for everyone in the household.
  • Ease of Maintenance: Cleaning a walk-in shower is generally more straightforward than a bathtub. The absence of hard-to-reach areas and the simpler design of walk-in showers allow for quicker, more efficient cleaning routines.
  • Lack of Soaking Option: One significant downside to showers is the absence of the ability to take a soak. For those who enjoy long baths to relax or soothe aches, a walk-in shower cannot provide this experience.
  • Potential for Water Splashes: Without careful design, showers can lead to water splashing outside the shower area, potentially creating slippery floors and necessitating additional cleanup.
  • Temperature Fluctuations: In some cases, open walk-in showers may not retain heat as well as enclosed tubs, leading to a chillier showering experience, especially in cooler climates like Wausau, WI.
  • Resale Considerations: While showers are trendy and appealing to many, the lack of a bathtub in a home can be a drawback for potential buyers with young children or those who prefer baths.
The Pros
  • Modern Aesthetics: Walk-in showers embody contemporary design, offering clean lines and an open feel that can significantly enhance the visual space of your bathroom. Their sleek appearance fits well with modern homes in Wausau, WI, and can be a focal point of bathroom design.
  • Space Efficiency: By eliminating the bulk of a traditional bathtub, showers can make a bathroom feel larger and more accessible. This is especially beneficial in smaller bathrooms where conserving space is crucial.
  • Water Conservation: With the installation of low-flow shower heads, walk-in showers can be more water-efficient than full baths in traditional bathtubs. This not only conserves water but can also help reduce utility bills over time.
  • Accessibility: Walk-in showers offer easier access, particularly for those with mobility issues. The lack of a high threshold to step over reduces the risk of falls, making the bathroom safer for everyone in the household.
  • Ease of Maintenance: Cleaning a walk-in shower is generally more straightforward than a bathtub. The absence of hard-to-reach areas and the simpler design of walk-in showers allow for quicker, more efficient cleaning routines.
The Cons
  • Lack of Soaking Option: One significant downside to showers is the absence of the ability to take a soak. For those who enjoy long baths to relax or soothe aches, a walk-in shower cannot provide this experience.
  • Potential for Water Splashes: Without careful design, showers can lead to water splashing outside the shower area, potentially creating slippery floors and necessitating additional cleanup.
  • Temperature Fluctuations: In some cases, open walk-in showers may not retain heat as well as enclosed tubs, leading to a chillier showering experience, especially in cooler climates like Wausau, WI.
  • Resale Considerations: While showers are trendy and appealing to many, the lack of a bathtub in a home can be a drawback for potential buyers with young children or those who prefer baths.

The Pros and Cons of Traditional Bathtubs

The Pros The Cons
  • Comfort and Relaxation: Traditional bathtubs offer the ultimate relaxation experience, allowing you to fully immerse and soak. This can be particularly soothing for sore muscles or just for enjoying a peaceful, meditative soak at the end of a long day.
  • Family-Friendly: For families with young children, bathtubs are often seen as a necessity. They make bath time easier and safer for little ones, providing a contained space for washing and playing.
  • Versatility in Design: Traditional bathtubs come in a variety of styles, sizes, and materials, allowing for a high degree of customization in your bathroom's design. Whether you're looking for a classic clawfoot tub or a modern alcove tub, there's likely a bathtub that fits your aesthetic preferences.
  • Resale Appeal to Broader Audience: While trends come and go, the appeal of a classic bathtub remains constant for many. Having a traditional bathtub in your home can appeal to a wider range of potential buyers, should you ever decide to sell.
  • Space Requirements: One of the biggest downsides to traditional bathtubs is the amount of floor space they occupy. In smaller bathrooms, a bathtub can make the space feel cramped and leave little room for other fixtures or storage.
  • Water Usage: Bathtubs typically require more water than showers for a full bath. This can lead to higher water bills and is less environmentally friendly, especially in areas where water conservation is a concern.
  • Accessibility Issues: For those with mobility issues, getting in and out of a traditional bathtub can pose a significant challenge and increase the risk of slips and falls.
  • Maintenance and Cleaning: Bathtubs can require more effort to clean compared to showers. The need to scrub the tub regularly to prevent soap scum and mildew build-up, along with cleaning around often cumbersome fixtures, can make maintenance more time-consuming.
The Pros
  • Comfort and Relaxation: Traditional bathtubs offer the ultimate relaxation experience, allowing you to fully immerse and soak. This can be particularly soothing for sore muscles or just for enjoying a peaceful, meditative soak at the end of a long day.
  • Family-Friendly: For families with young children, bathtubs are often seen as a necessity. They make bath time easier and safer for little ones, providing a contained space for washing and playing.
  • Versatility in Design: Traditional bathtubs come in a variety of styles, sizes, and materials, allowing for a high degree of customization in your bathroom's design. Whether you're looking for a classic clawfoot tub or a modern alcove tub, there's likely a bathtub that fits your aesthetic preferences.
  • Resale Appeal to Broader Audience: While trends come and go, the appeal of a classic bathtub remains constant for many. Having a traditional bathtub in your home can appeal to a wider range of potential buyers, should you ever decide to sell.
The Cons
  • Space Requirements: One of the biggest downsides to traditional bathtubs is the amount of floor space they occupy. In smaller bathrooms, a bathtub can make the space feel cramped and leave little room for other fixtures or storage.
  • Water Usage: Bathtubs typically require more water than showers for a full bath. This can lead to higher water bills and is less environmentally friendly, especially in areas where water conservation is a concern.
  • Accessibility Issues: For those with mobility issues, getting in and out of a traditional bathtub can pose a significant challenge and increase the risk of slips and falls.
  • Maintenance and Cleaning: Bathtubs can require more effort to clean compared to showers. The need to scrub the tub regularly to prevent soap scum and mildew build-up, along with cleaning around often cumbersome fixtures, can make maintenance more time-consuming.
Interior of a modern bathroom with shower, in a small apartment, with white marble tiles

FAQ: Choosing Between Traditional Bathtubs and Walk-In Showers

Yes, installing a walk-in shower can increase your home’s value, especially if it enhances the overall aesthetic and functionality of the bathroom. 

However, it’s important to consider the potential buyers’ preferences in your area. In some markets, having at least one bathtub in the home is also valuable.

In most cases, yes. Walk-in showers can often be designed to fit into the existing space of a traditional bathtub, making them an ideal option for bathroom remodels aimed at improving space efficiency and modernizing the look.

The cost can vary depending on the materials used, the size of the shower, and any additional features (like custom tiling or high-end fixtures). 

Generally, walk-in showers can be more expensive due to the level of customization and detail involved, but they also offer significant benefits in terms of design and accessibility.

The installation time for a walk-in shower can be similar to or slightly longer than that for a traditional bathtub, depending on the complexity of the shower design and whether any structural modifications are needed. 

A straightforward replacement can often be completed within a few days.

Yes, walk-in tubs are designed with safety in mind, featuring low entry thresholds, non-slip flooring, and grab bars. They are an excellent option for those with mobility issues or anyone who prioritizes safety in the bathroom.
Space permitting, you can have both a walk-in shower and a tub in your bathroom. This combination offers the best of both worlds in terms of functionality and design appeal, catering to a wide range of needs and preferences.

Need Help Choosing? Let's Talk Today!

Confused about whether to install a bathtub or a walk-in shower in your Wausau home? Remodeling Journey is here to clear up the confusion. Our experts are ready to assist you in making the best choice for your space. Contact us now and let’s turn your bathroom into a sanctuary! (715) 551-7328